"Queer Eye" Muzzled at North Carolina High School
A big part of running for office is running a catchy public relations
campaign. It’s all about getting—and keeping—people’s attention.
Jarred Gamwell, a 17-year-old junior at James Hunt High School in Wilson,
North Carolina, obviously knew this when he penned some of the posters he
would eventually plaster on the school walls in his effort to snag the
student council presidency there.
Any good candidate knows you have to peddle your assets to your voting
public.
And Gamwell certainly has enough of them.
He’s got a stellar grade point average. He tutors fellow students. He
plays the saxophone. And he competes in the Science Olympiad.
I don’t know about James Hunt High, but I know when I was in school,
these attributes—honorable as they all are—wouldn’t have appealed much
to my fellow students. In fact, those attributes alone probably would have
gotten you labeled a geek.
It’s been a long time since I’ve walked the corridors of a high
school, but I imagine today isn’t so much different than in generations
past. When you are running for student council president, along with your
achievements, you have to be able to sell some sort of "cool
factor," or something that sets you apart, makes you stand out. There’s
got to be something unique that makes people stand up and notice you.
James Gamwell knew exactly what that angle in his campaign would be: In
addition to being intelligent and musically talented, he’s also gay.
In some places, being gay is even considered hip and cool.
From the slogans Gamwell eventually penned, it’s obvious he took note
of the pop culture coolness that being gay now enjoys in many circles. Two
of his posters read, "Queer Eye for Hunt High," and "Gay Guys
Know Everything!"
But in addition to catching his fellow students’ attention, Gamwell
says he just wanted to be honest with them, too.
"All I wanted to do was be open about who I am and let other
students know that if they elect me president I’ll welcome and accept
diversity and a variety of ideas," he says.
But for Hunt High School’s principal, Bill Williamson, the posters were
anything but cool or catchy or admirable for their honesty.
Somehow, he found them offensive. And he had them pulled down.
According to Gamwell’s account, he hung the two posters in question on
school walls on the morning of April 20. He noticed that by the end of the
next class, the posters were missing.
That afternoon, he was called to the office of the vice principal. There,
he found his missing posters. The vice principal told Gamwell the posters
could not be put back up. When Gamwell asked why, the vice principal told
him to take the matter up with the principal.
The next day, Gamwell went to the principal’s office. By Gamwell’s
accounts, Williamson admitted he was the one who had the posters removed,
but wouldn’t tell Gamwell why.
Gamwell says he told the principal it was important to his campaign to
get his message out, so students would get to know him and see his pride; so
he could convey the message that if he was elected student body president,
he wouldn’t discriminate against other students; and because he thought
his slogans were clever.
Gamwell says he tried for two days to get a verbal and written response
from the principal. He says all he got was a smarmy answer saying that
principals don’t have to justify their actions to students.
That’s when Gamwell went to the American Civil Liberties Union. The
ACLU has intervened on his behalf, demanding not only that the posters be
allowed to be put back up in the halls, but also that Gamwell be allowed to
address the issue of his sexual orientation—and the school’s censorship—in
his speech to the student body.
In press reports that have followed, the school district’s attorney,
David Orcutt, defended the principal’s actions, saying the posters were
taken down because "the language was inappropriate." School
spokespeople have also said the posters were "disruptive of the
educational process" and "irrelevant" to the campaign for
student body president.
Bill Williamson may not feel like he has to explain his actions to his
students, but he does have to follow the United States Constitution, and
this is a pretty clear case of censoring political speech. The Supreme Court
has ruled repeatedly that while the rights of high school kids may be more
limited than those of adults, their free speech is still protected.
On legal grounds, this is a pretty clear-cut case.
But what is more interesting than the legal implications are the social
ones. And they are also more optimistic for gay and lesbian kids.
The powers that be—meaning the old fogies—who run the high school
somehow deemed the "language" of the posters untenable because
they mentioned the word "gay." To them, "gay" is still a
dirty word, because in their minds, it’s still about sex—not sexual
orientation.
But young Jarred Gamwell, and likely many of his schoolmates, understands
the difference. Furthermore, the young generation is far less likely to be
"offended" by Gamwell’s statement. Who knows, many of them may
even be impressed with it, and with Gamwell’s honesty and courage. I know
I am.
Those are two more qualities that would suit him well as president of
James Hunt High School.
The kid sure gets my vote.
Mubarak Dahir is editor of The Express, the GLBT newspaper in Fort
Lauderdale, FL. He may be reached at