Move Over Tinky-Winky; It’s SpongeBob’s Turn to Sweat
Among my fondest memories of childhood are the countless Saturday
mornings spent watching cartoon shows on television. Mighty Mouse was my
favorite character, and I loved it when the tiny caped crusader soared
through the sky belting out his anthem in an operatic tenor: "Here I
Come to Save the Day..." Always heroic, Mighty was my kind of mouse;
I respected him a lot more than that silly little rodent Mickey— though
I was captivated by Mickey’s pal Goofy.
Actually, it was all great fun. My sister and I would be transfixed for
hours by our animated friends—Tom & Jerry, Roadrunner, Elmer Fudd
and Mr. Magoo, to name but a few. And we were fortunate that, even though
it was the conservative 1950s, our parents weren’t bombarded with dire
warnings from politicos disparaging the content of our beloved shows. Our
mother kept an eye on what we were viewing, and she did sometimes worry
that the paranormal aspects of Casper the Friendly Ghost might give us
nightmares. But that never happened. In fact, Casper spread a wonderfully
upbeat message about the nature of friendship—and the importance of not
turning away from those who are different than us. Today, he’d probably
get in trouble for espousing such a point of view.
Cartoons, especially those with a social subtext, have been on my mind
a lot lately. For one thing, there’s a new kid in our family. Benjamin
Arthur Novotny, nicknamed "Ben Jammin" because he sleeps all day
and parties all night, is the first newborn we’ve had to gloat over in
nearly three decades. He is my niece Kerry’s son, and at four weeks old,
he already squints at the glowing TV screen as if he’s expecting it to
deliver some kind of enlightenment. (Ben’s parents have tried to help,
tuning to the Discovery Channel, but much of its programming is about
bikers. And the Learning Channel is full of hotrods and casinos.)
If Ben is anything like his great uncle (or most kids), he will soon
start acquiring a good deal of information from the bunnies, bears, and
other curious denizens of television’s animated kingdom. I wonder what
characters and programs will become his favorites. But it troubles me
that, if some rightwing zealots have their way, Ben will be denied the
opportunity to experience some of the better children’s programming
being created today.
The conservatives’ campaign against cartoon creatures began five
years ago with the attempted "outing" of Teletubby Tinky-Winky,
who was denigrated for strutting around in a purple jumpsuit and carrying
a red handbag. (Word is that he went on to become a founding member of the
Red Hat Society.)
At the time, a lot of us laughed off the attacks against Tinky as
ludicrous chatter from the lunatic fringe. But in the current political
climate, the rabid right has been emboldened. In recent weeks, it has
intensified its attacks on animation, including characters old and new.
Among them, veteran "Peanuts" tribe member Peppermint Patty,
Nickelodeon’s phenomenally popular SpongeBob SquarePants and rising PBS
star Buster the bunny. All of the characters are being decried for
advancing the "gay agenda"—though I have never been able to
figure out where I can get my copy of that schema.
Poor SpongeBob is absorbing the self-righteous wrath of the Focus on
the Family lobby. As an underwater invertebrate with a porous, fibrous
skeleton, Bob is not likely to have much of a sex life, but FOF founder
James Dobson finds it unconscionable that he holds hands with his sidekick
Patrick and enjoys watching a pretend TV show called The Adventures of
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy.
If that’s not enough to square the pants off you, Dobson claims that
there’s an even bigger problem: SpongeBob has been recruited for a
"pro-homosexual video" in which he sings the song We Are Family
with such other cartoon notables as Barney the dinosaur, Clifford the Big
Red Dog and Jimmy Neutron. (Quick, let’s dig up J. Edgar Hoover and
start a list.)
No one can deny that "We Are Family" has been an anthem of
the gay community for the last two decades. But, following the attacks of
Sept. 11, the song’s writer, Niles Rodgers, decided that its message of
inclusion would be appropriate for teaching youngsters about
multiculturalism. The resulting video, which is scheduled to be shown at
schools, makes no reference whatsoever to any form of sexuality, gay,
straight or otherwise.
Not one to be swayed by facts, Dobson has continued his smear campaign,
citing a "tolerance pledge" that appears on the "We Are
Family" website (but not the video). Created by the Southern Poverty
Law Center, the pledge includes sexual orientation as one of many reasons
not to be mean to someone. That’s enough of a link for Focus on Family
fluky Paul Batura to decry the video as a "insidious" and
"a classic bait and switch.... The [We Are Family] organization is
manipulating and potentially brainwashing kids."
So, there you have it: SpongeBob and his coconspirators are soaking the
brains of children with open-mindedness—a behavior the FOF simply cannot
abide. There’s nothing like tolerance to make a reactionary intolerant.
But Bob isn’t the only one in hot water. Also accused of advancing
the agenda is an animated rabbit who hops around the country dropping in
on real-life human beings from various walks of life in the PBS series
Postcards from Buster. The show offers youngsters a look at the diverse
ways people work and live—unless the people depicted are too diverse for
the Bush administration. When new Education Secretary Margaret Spellings
caught wind of a segment featuring a maple-syrup producing lesbian couple
and their three children in Vermont, she objected. "Many parents
would not want their young children exposed to the lifestyle"
depicted, she said.
She must be talking about syrup-making, because the program’s content
includes no discussion of or references to homosexuality. However, the
mere fact that it shows a gay family (without criticism) as a part of the
fabric of our society has sent Spellings reeling. She has
"strongly" recommended that PBS reimburse the Department of
Education for all public money spent to produce the episode. Meanwhile,
our one-and-only public-television network has delayed the scheduled
broadcast in order to give each member station a chance to preview and, if
they so wish, ban it.
Clearly, the forces of intolerance are doing everything within their
growing power to make sure that no positive images of gay people reach the
airwaves—and that children in particular are denied all access to
evidence that we even exist.
Fortunately for my great-nephew, his mom and dad are as infuriated as I
am about the political attacks on animated artistry and lessons in
diversity. But at least Ben will grow up with the advantage of knowing his
openly gay aunt (on his dad’s side) and his openly gay uncle (me)—as
well as our respective life partners. And when we all get together, we’ll
have a laugh watching the videotape collection I intend to compile for him
featuring SpongeBob, Barney, Tinky-Winky, Buster the bunny and good old
Peppermint Patty. Not to mention a little Mighty Mouse, whose services may
once again be required to save the day.
Bill Sievert can be reached at