The Lesson of Brokeback
To say that I am a little obsessed with the film Brokeback Mountain
would be exaggeration—but only a slight one. Like many Letters’
readers, I’m sure, this brilliant film directed by Ang Lee touched me
deeply, and its stark and tragic story continued to replay in my mind for
a far longer time than I usually expect, even for a film of this caliber.
(As an aside, I suppose I should also confess that I’d watch almost
anything with Jake Gyllenhaal in the cast, and though Steve usually agrees
with me on that, even he vetoed a recent suggestion that we watch The Day
After Tomorrow for the third—or maybe the fourth—time last week.)
I bring up Brokeback Mountain here because its story tells us something
important about ourselves, not just as gay people but as human beings.
Brokeback Mountain is the story of two men—Ennis del Mar and Jack Twist—who
hide their love from the world around them and even from themselves.
Ultimately it is a story about the destructive nature of life in the
closet and the sickness of a society that demands it. Brokeback Mountain
graphically illustrates how the closet can become to the soul like a
splinter buried deep in the flesh—its pain and inflamation affecting the
entire body.
Sometimes the excuse of the closet is a sense that it protects the
loved ones in our lives; all too often, it simply alienates friends and
family and destroys the relationships it sought to save in the first
place. In truth, there is no relationship—there is no contact—when
there is a closed door between human beings. The love that Jack and Ennis
had for one another could not survive in the vacuum of the closet, and its
eventual implosion touched and damaged all the other people close to them.
One of the great tools of a society bent on preserving the closet is
silence. Silence is the closet. In a recent interview in Newsweek
magazine, Ang Lee was asked, "...are you surprised that Brokeback
Mountain hasn’t raised more protest from the religious right?" He
responded: "I didn’t know they would take a position of deliberate
quietness, so that they wouldn’t [inadvertently] promote the
movie."
Change never comes about because of silence, which is one reason that
conservative churches (or other institutions for that matter) don’t want
open dialogue about GLBT issues. As long as they can simply point a finger
and scream "sinner," they don’t have to open the closet door.
To engage in a true dialogue about the differences in our beliefs—to
have a true conversation with one another, person to person, human to
human—necessitates the opening of the closet door. Change happens when
we open doors. When we come out to our family, our family is changed. When
we come out in our church, our church is changed. When we come out in our
school, our school is changed. When we come out in our community, our
community is changed.
I believe with all my heart that we are living the change. At times our
opponents seem more vocal and organized than ever, but that is in direct
proportion to our success and visibility in the world around us, and we
must not be intimidated by them. The Advocate recently reported that among
high school seniors in the class of 2006, 74% supported legalized same-sex
marriage or civil unions—think about what those figures would have been
just a few short years ago.
When we started CAMP Rehoboth 16 years ago, it was about coming out,
not just as individuals, but as a community. We were responding to the
need to be visible, to be heard, to become a part of the community around
us. I clearly remember the first year that this magazine appeared on the
streets of our town. There was both support and opposition from both
straight and gay people in our community. Change can be frightful to all
of us, but once we get through it, it is rarely as frightening as we
imagined it would be. The same can be said for coming out of the closet—it
affects us all, the individual, the family, the church, the community, the
society as a whole.
The CAMP Rehoboth Community Center is about the health of our
community, both gay and straight. It is about keeping the doors of the
closet standing wide open—no, on second thought, it’s about removing
them altogether—so that we can reach out and touch one another, neighbor
to neighbor, person to person, human to human.
2006 will be an important year for the CAMP Rehoboth Community Center
and we will be pushing hard all the way through the year to not only meet
our goals, but to exceed them. Perhaps if Jack and Ennis even had the
smallest inkling that a place like this could exist, their story would
have had a very different ending.
Murray Archibald is an artist and President of the Board of Directors
of CAMP Rehoboth. He can be reached at