Whisker of Evil
By Rita Mae Brown & Sneaky Pie Brown
Bantam, 297 pp. $24.95
The dynamic duo of Rita Mae Brown and her feline collaborator, Sneaky
Pie Brown, are at it again. In this, their 12th book (13th if you count
Sneaky Pie’s Cookbook for Mystery Lovers) the duo returns us to Crozet,
Virginia, the home of Postmistress Mary "Harry" Haristeen and
her quadruped partners-in-crime-solving, fearless corgi Tee Tucker, and
frisky felines Mrs. Murphy and Pewter.
Crozet may be pictured as a charming small town, oozing with southern
charm and populated with good neighborly folks, but for such an idyllic
place, there a whole lot of murderin’ goin’ on!
While this book is billed as a Mrs. Murphy Mystery (as are all of
Sneaky Pie’s), its largest appeal will be to fans of the genre and
animal lovers of all stripes. If you’re a true mystery lover you’ll
probably be happier curling up with a Dan Brown or Patricia Cornwell
novel. There are scads of animals to love. And they all talk. Cross
species and territorial rights don’t slow them down a bit. There’s
Tootsie Roll-loving Simon the possum, Flatface the owl, an unnamed blue
jay, and vixen (fox variety) all who jabber away at each other throughout
the book.
Harry and her sidekicks are out taking a walk on a balmy summer morning
when they stumble across the body of Barry Monteith as he lays dying. His
throat has been ripped out and it is initially assumed that he was
attacked by an animal. There are no immediate other signs on or near the
body, and a subsequent autopsy reveals that Barry had been infected with
rabies several weeks before he died. Searching for clues near where the
body was found, Harry finds a small gold school ring with distinctive
markings and a Latin inscription. It’s discovered that the ring belongs
to Mary Pat Reines who has been missing, along with her prized
thoroughbred, Ziggy Flame, since 1974,
Barry Monteith was a horse breeder in partnership with Sugar Thierry.
The plot thickens when a few weeks later Sugar dies a mysterious death.
Mysterious until Harry describes his symptoms just before he died. Another
diagnosed death by rabies throws the town into an uproar and attracts the
attention of the media, setting off a frenzy of speculation about the
infections and how far they may spread. The news that the deaths were
caused by the strain of rabies, found in silver-haired bats, does little
to calm the panic gripping many of the townspeople intent on shooting
dogs, cats and any other animal that might fall under suspicion.
There’s an awful lot to be learned about rabies in this book, maybe
even more than the average person wants to know. And, there’s even more
information about thoroughbred horses, those bred for the track,
steeplechase, and fox hunting. While some of it is mildly interesting, it
does get a little tedious to repeatedly have horse lineage listed
especially when the majority of it does nothing to move the plot forward.
Rita Mae’s love of horses is quite obvious, but why saddle a reader with
so much detail?
The book does have a very small lesbian subplot. Alicia Palmer, a
former resident of Crozet who left in the seventies and took Hollywood by
storm returns to the estate left to her by Mary Pat Raines. The two were
lovers for three years. Alicia was under suspicion when Mary Pat first
disappeared, because she inherited so much from her. Thirty plus years
later that cloud returns with new facts about Mary Pat’s disappearance
that links to the new murders.
The animals are quicker to figure out all the answers before the
humans, proving, well I’m not quite sure what. All in all, the book is
pretty folksy, and the actual "whodunit" is sort of
anticlimactic and feels rushed and sort of crammed in near the end. One of
the characters in the book says "...there are people in this county
who haven’t had a new thought in thirty years and don’t want
one." That sort of sums up, at least for me, Sneaky Pie and Rita Mae’s
formulaic Mrs. Murphy Mysteries.