Hate Thy Gay Neighbor
Who wouldn’t want a homosexual for a neighbor?
Our interior and exterior decorating skills are legendary. We keep a
tidy lawn and a colorful garden. And in city after city, we renovate and
update, raising property values for ourselves and those around us.
To top it off, we’re avid neighborhood activists, throwing ourselves
into better policing, stricter zoning and removal of "unsavory
elements."
Who wouldn’t want a homosexual for a neighbor? Plenty of people, as
it turns out.
Asked who they would not want as neighbors, one in five residents of
Western Europe, the U.S., Canada, Australia and New Zealand said
"no" to the gay next door. That’s fully double the number who
said they wouldn’t want Jews or someone of a different race for a
neighbor.
The papers may be full of stories about resentment toward immigrants
and foreign workers, but gays are less welcome to the neighborhood by more
than 50 percent. Even Muslims, with all their bad press, are 25 percent
more accepted.
The somewhat surprising findings are from work done by researchers at
universities in Northern Ireland and New Zealand. Since few among us would
admit outright to being a bigot, these academics found that the best way
of measuring bigotry is a more indirect inquiry into what types of people
you wouldn’t want to live nearby.
If you believe, as many of us do, that homophobia is the last
acceptable prejudice, you’ll find support in the study. In two-thirds of
the countries surveyed, gays were rated the least desirable neighbors,
including in the U.S., Canada and Australia, where the numbers who
disapproved of gay neighbors were more than double that of Muslims, the
next group down the list. Only in a few countries in Scandinavia and
northern Europe were we welcomed by almost everyone.
And among the bigots, we were by far the favored target of loathing. In
most major Western countries, including the U.S., Canada and Great
Britain, more than three-quarters of those who object to at least one
minority group also include gays on their list of phobias. That led the
researchers to conclude, "Homophobia is, by far, the main source of
bigotry in most Western countries."
What, in turn, is the source of that homophobia? Not a person’s level
of education or income, as it turns out. Age and gender were much better
indicators. A New York Times poll released last week backs that up,
showing opposition to legal recognition for gay couples running 40 to 50
percent higher among Americans over the age of 30 than it is among those
under 30.
It’s a pretty safe bet that the 23 percent of Americans who don’t
want gay neighbors form the bulk of those who also don’t want our
relationships to receive legal recognition. I’ve always resisted the
idea that opponents of gay rights are bigots. It has struck me as a cheap
shot that polarizes the debate, rather than attempting to reason and
address concerns. There’s not much point in reasoning with prejudice, of
course; the whole idea is that it’s animus immune to reality.
Religion can be as impenetrable to reason as prejudice, and gay rights
opponents have long cited their moral beliefs as justification for our
inequality. Still, since I come from a loving, religious family that is
steadfastly opposed to my equal rights as a gay man, I’ve always taken
the anti-gay Christians at their word when they swear it’s the sin they
hate and not the sinner.
So how do they explain the "good neighbor" study’s most
surprising finding? Deeply religious Christians were less prejudiced
against Muslims and immigrants, and much more prejudiced against gays. Do
these churchgoers simply ignore Jesus’ central commandment to "love
thy neighbor"? Or are they figuring that if Jesus commands them to
love their neighbor, they hope for Christ’s sake their neighbor isn’t
queer?
As more lesbians and gay men live their lives openly, there’s hope
the bigotry might fade, as it has on race. The short-lived ABC reality
show Welcome to the Neighborhood effectively tested out the findings of
the "good neighbor" study, letting a group of mildly bigoted
Texas neighbors award a house on their block to either a black family, a
Korean family, hippies, Wiccans or a gay couple. The series was yanked
because it pushed too many racial hot-buttons, but the gay couple won over
their skeptical neighbors and won the house, too.
One objection to the show was from "fair housing" advocates,
who pointed out federal law prohibits discriminating on the basis of race,
religion, and national origin in the housing market. Of course that law
doesn’t include sexual orientation as a protected category, and
absolutely no one is talking about amending it anytime soon.
But as the gay couple on Welcome to the Neighbor-hood proved, the
answer to neighborhood bigotry may not be in changing laws, but in
changing hearts and minds. We have always been our own best ambassadors,
and perhaps if we keep extending our welcome mat, one day more
"deeply religious" folks will do the same.