Memoirs of a Singing Bar-Fly
It’s been dished that if there are at least 10 gays in a community,
there will be a piano bar where show-queens and other frustrated
Merman/Larry Kert wannabees strut their stuff from night to night, while
consuming generous quantities of alcohol. I know that Rehoboth has
Partners and it’s one of the best.
Time was, Manhattan boasted several of these havens for Hammerstein or
Hart fans, places where one could while away an evening, barking along as
the in-house pianist tore through the scores of popular Broadway musicals.
The number of such establishments has dwindled, due to an aging
population—hell, you’ve got to be at least 50 to remember Broadway’s
"Golden Age." If you are younger than that, there has got to be
at least one show-queen in your gene pool.
But, for those of you who enjoy belting out showstoppers in a dark,
secluded place where no one else will know your face, I recommend that, on
your next visit to my beloved Big Apple,you spend at least one evening at
Manhattan’s best known piano bar, Rose’s Turn.
Located at 55 Grove Street, just west of Sheridan Square, on a charming
block that has retained most of its elegance in the face of crass
developers who want to turn this town into one, big shopping mall, (but
that’s another story) Rose’s Turn (and every last one of you should
know from whence that name comes*) can offer a really fun evening of
show-stoppers and congeniality.
Rose’s Turn which has hardly changed at all since my first visit in
1978, is a cozy room, discreetly and dimly lit. There are 16 seats around
the bar, little tables around which 20 or so smallish people can be
seated, and a compact floor that seems to allow hundreds—ok—scores of
people to stand around drinking and singing. There’s a full bar but no
food is served, prices are moderate by Manhattan standards. I’m a
retired drinker, and my diet coke set me back $3.50—better double that
for a cocktail.
A recent weeknight visit found attendance a bit light (it was raining)
and other than myself (I have no shame!) no one wanted to sing—no
problem, the excellent pianist entertained us royally just by playing some
grand and glorious songs by Weill, Porter, Kander et. al.
My experience (and I’ve been going to Rose’s Turn for decades) is
that the large crowds appear on weekends. Sometimes, would-be customers
must wait outside until there’s some turnover.
On a Friday or Saturday night, one can take part in medleys from
everything from Oklahoma! to Into the Woods and lots in between. Some
pianists there resort to the honorable use of "fake books,"
(books of sheet music, cribbed and photocopied and cobbled together) while
others play dozens and dozens of songs from memory. Certain individuals
known to the pianist are entrusted with singing solos, even entire
numbers.
One night, some months ago, the bill of fare was Hello Dolly!, and I
thought I was doing pretty well from the bar, when a guy with a big, white
hat and what looked like a dress worn by Carol Channing, pushed his way up
to the pianist and performed the show’s title song.
To make matters worse, I knew and despised this fellow from my misspent
youth, and have been known to cross streets to avoid talking to him. As
soon as he was done singing, he spotted me, dashed to my side and greeted
me with a bear hug, much to the amusement of my friends in the bar.
Speaking of romance, Rose’s Turn gets a mixed, gay crowd. Folks seem
to bring their dates to this particular bar instead of seeking out new
conquests.
On a crowded night, there’s really no room to cruise anyway. Of
course you might see that stranger across that crowded room, but if you
do, you might have a lot of trouble flying to his/her side.
Frankly, I’ve not yet found romance there. But of course, I come to
Rose’s Turn to sing.
I have a really, truly horrible voice (I should be at the Met, the
oasis for voices like mine), but I can stay on pitch within my three or
four note range, and I usually know the lyrics.
So I go there, sing, don’t get asked NOT to sing, and have fun. I
think you’ll have fun there, too, if you like giving back everything you
learned from original cast albums, all these years.
Don’t feel if you’re young and untaught about pre-Annie show music,
that you don’t belong in a piano bar.Everybody can learn something new,
or something wonderful. Sing along as best you can, most people can
recognize "Tonight" and "I Could Have Danced All
Night." Ask the person next to you—you know, It’s an very ancient
saying, but a true and honest thought, that if you become a teacher, by
your pupils you’ll be taught. Bearing that in mind, I’m sure folks
will be glad to impart some Broadway lore.
Pleasant and unpretentious, Rose’s Turn (or the piano bar of your
choice) is a fine place to spend an evening getting in touch with your
inner Mary Martin. Let’s not let the tradition disappear!
(* Okay, a cheat sheet for newbies to Broadway: Rose’s Turn is the
showstopping final number in Gypsy, as previously sung by Ethel Merman,
Angela Lansbury, Tyne Daly, Bette Midler, Bernadette Peters, take your
pick….)
Kenn Harris is a NYC theatre and music critic and author of the
biography of opera diva Renata Tebaldi, and The Ultimate Opera Quiz Book.
Kenn is an opera devotee and big time collector of original cast albums
from Broadway and around the world. He loves to dish and has been released
in the custody of Momolo and Anzoletta, his feline associates."
Contact him at