I used to think I was the only one. The only
one who had grown up in a fundamentalist home, rejecting supposedly
Biblical notions of what it meant to be a woman or a man. The only one who
struggled with the confines of what I had been told my life was going to
be like. What it should be like.
For a long time, what a psychologist acquaintance refers to as
"terminal uniqueness" kept me isolated and lonely. The term
makes me smile now, having survived the traumas brought on by the despair
of feeling alone. Eventually, I came to recognize similar themes in other
people’s lives.
After all, most of us in the GLBTQ community have embarked on similar
journeys, whether or not the exact paths were discernibly similar. For
instance, the road I took meandered through over achievement, anorexia,
emotional and physical abuse, the agony of thinking I had to choose
between spirituality and sexuality—and a host of other things that could
have cost me my job, my sanity and even my life.
Being able to recognize the milestones and pitfalls of my own journey
is why I was a bit surprised but not shocked to find out I have a good bit
in common with a (gay male) former porn star. I made this discovery after
reconnecting with a colleague I had worked alongside during a political
campaign. I learned he is the author of a book, Secrets of a Gay Marine
Porn Star, and he gave me an advance copy.
On the surface, we’d have little in common except a penchant for the
political and advocacy for the gay community. Still, our souls seemed very
similar. After all, the author— Rich Merritt’s—formative years were
spent inside the "fortress of fundamentalism," and it shaped his
early perceptions of who he was and how he was to live, and warped the way
he approached decisions later in life.
Instead of spiritual insight and a helpful roadmap for life, Rich
developed self-doubt and a naive and narrow view of the world. He tells
the story of attending Bob Jones Academy and Bob Jones University, where
he heard message after message that "different" is bad.
Especially if that differentness was same-gender attraction.
Beyond the obvious commonalities of the religion in which we were
raised, the book reminded me of how gays and lesbians too often embrace
the vicious cycles fostered by supposedly well-meaning institutions. I’ve
seen too many repeat the pattern of trying nearly anything to gain
validation, only to be ripped apart internally by the charade.
In Rich’s case, he wrestles with stringent religious dogma, flouts
military policies in semi-secrecy and, nearly always, feels a sharp degree
of self-hatred. As you might guess, Rich ultimately explodes into
self-destructive behavior and jeopardizes his most cherished
relationships. For instance, he finds temporary solace from body-image
issues as a go-go dancer, as an escort and, eventually, as a porn actor.
The rage he feels at the increasing dichotomy between who he was
"supposed" to be and who he actually was sounded and felt too
much like my own story—and those of many others. What the now-former
porn star figures out is that there aren’t enough good grades, medals,
law school accolades, sex, drugs, alcohol, pornography, parties or even
relationships to make him feel whole. Something I eventually learned as
well.
The paths we stumble down while pushing through the mind-numbing,
heart-wrenching fog of someone else’s dreams or wishes may differ, but I
hope more and more of my gay sisters and brothers more quickly
differentiate between the life we were meant to live and the life we’ve
been told we should live and embrace the one of our own creation.
Many have gone before us and can shed light on our unique courses to
feeling whole and connected. In the meantime, recognizing and remembering
that we share a common experience can give us hope when we aren’t sure
we can find our way and fill us with the compassion to reach out to others
who are struggling.
In a time of rampant, divide-and-conquer fundamentalism, it’s crucial
that we remember we’re more alike than we sometimes want to admit. After
all, if I identify with a gay Marine porn star, who knows whose story just
might parallel your own?
Cynthia Abel lives in Atlanta, Georgia. She may be reached by e-mail
at