On May 17, Even the Jaded and Bored Had to Be
Moved
I don’t like the word jaded, because it has too harsh of an edge to it,
but when you are a reporter and editor, you do develop a thick skin. You
have to. You can’t do this job well without a healthy dose of skepticism.
Questioning and challenging everything that anyone tells you is at the heart
of this profession.
We’re trained to be non-emotional about things. To look at news and
events objectively, sometimes even coldly. Not getting involved is the
hallmark of what we do.
One of the things you constantly hear as a journalist is how
"historic" something is. The word buzzes about a journalist more
than flies at a picnic. It’s annoying, and it’s gotten to the point that
any time someone approaches me with a pitch for a story and starts off by
telling me that whatever he or she wants me to cover is
"historic," I roll my eyes. I may even tune out altogether.
It’s been impossible to tune out the story about gays and lesbians
fighting for equal marriage rights. It’s been headline news all around the
country for months—including in this publication—ever since the
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled last November that denying
marriage licenses to same-sex couples violated the Massachusetts
Constitution.
In the long waiting period between the court ruling and this past May 17—when
marriage licenses finally began being issued—there’s been an
overwhelming amount of news about "gay marriage."
San Francisco even upstaged Massachusetts when its defiant mayor began
issuing marriage licenses to same sex couples despite California state law
that prohibits gay unions. Thousands of couples showed up to tie the knot
there, before the practice was halted by the courts.
In tiny New Paltz, New York, the young, straight mayor there took a
similar stand, and boldly officiated at same-sex weddings, until he was
threatened with legal action unless he stopped.
And in Portland, Oregon, officials noted there was nothing in state law
to prohibit them from handing out marriage licenses to same-sex couples, so
they began doing so. They, too, continued until a legal challenge forced
them to stop, while the issue is being settled in court.
Each time I read about these acts of civil disobedience, I cheered on
both the straight officials acting as agents of change, and the gay and
lesbian couples willing to stand up and put their relationships on the
political line.
I think it’s been an excellent exercise in civil justice, for us as gay
and lesbian people, and for the millions of straight Americans who have now
seen on their TV screens and in their newspaper pages important images of
committed gay and lesbian couples exchanging vows and pledging to love one
another—just as heterosexual couples have done forever.
But I have to admit, even as a supporter of same-sex marriage rights, in
the past few months I’ve gotten a little saturated with "gay
marriage" news.
Every day, it seemed, there was something else happening on the same-sex
marriage front: A handful of gay and lesbian couples filing a new lawsuit in
yet another state (including two here in Florida); gay and lesbian couples
showing up at clerks offices, applying for marriage licenses, even though
they knew they’d be rejected; legislators proposing that their states add
a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriages, even though most of
those same states already have a law prohibiting them; the president
promoting a federal amendment to the U.S. Constitution that would prohibit
same-sex marriage anywhere in the United States; angry religious zealots
waving signs and screaming that gays and lesbians who try to get married are
going to hell; and the endless line of politicians declaring where they
stand on homosexual weddings.
All of this is important stuff, of course, and stuff that I’ve edited
and reported and commented on dutifully.
But I couldn’t help getting a little bored of every story about another
gay couple showing up to fill out a marriage application, only to be
rejected, as expected. Or of another right-winger proclaiming the end of
civilization, or of that annoying Massachusetts governor, Mitt Romney,
struggling day in and day out to find some sort of loophole that would stop
marriage in Massachusetts.
Of course, the marriage advocates within the gay and lesbian community
kept hitting up us journalists to continue coverage of every burp and sigh
along the way because it was all—you guessed it—"historic."
Late on the evening of Sunday, May 16, I checked my e-mail, and found one
with the subject line "Countdown at 3 minutes!" referring to the
fact that, when the e-mail was sent, it was three minutes before midnight,
and thus three minutes before the date that gays and lesbians could get
totally legal marriage licenses in Massachusetts.
I confess that when I read the subject line, I rolled my eyes.
Intellectually, I recognized how important May 17 would be. But with six
months of overload, and all the hype and build up to it, I wasn’t sure I
could get as psyched as the friend who sent me that three-minute e-mail.
Then May 17 came. I watched as people like Marcia Hams, 56, and her
partner of 27 years, Susan Shepherd, 52, became the first same-sex couple to
tie the knot in Massachusetts, and then cut a huge three-tiered wedding cake
at Cambridge, Massachusetts City Hall.
Later in the day, scores of men and women walked out of city halls all
around Massachusetts, triumphantly waving their marriage licenses in their
hands, and showing off gold wedding bands.
Some were laughing, some were crying, but they were all euphoric. This
huge political and legal and religious debate had suddenly, once again,
turned deeply personal for these people, and for all of us who are gay and
lesbian, whether we are in Massachusetts getting married, or just marveling
from afar.
I looked at those images of gay and lesbian people clutching onto their
wedding licenses, and to each other, and I instantly knew one
incontrovertible truth: What we were all witnessing was historic.
Mubarak Dahir is editor of The Express, the GLBT newspaper in Fort
Lauderdale, FL. He may be reached at