Statement by Judy and Dennis Shepard
Opposing the Federal Marriage Amendment
"Anyone that believes that the hatred behind this amendment is any
different than the hatred that was the cause of our son’s murder is
fooling themselves and doesn’t understand what is happening every day in
our society."
After viewing the President’s press conference earlier this month and
the Senate debate which followed regarding the so-called "Marriage
Protection Amendment", we feel compelled to respond to those who
would write discrimination into the Constitution.
It was hatred directed towards the gay, lesbian, bisexual and
transgender (GLBT) community that personally harmed our family and took
away our son, Matthew, not the love and commitment expressed each and
every day between same-sex couples. Love is the foundation for marriage,
not a threat to it. That love should be celebrated by society, not
diminished. The love and strength of the GLBT community and their allies
that helped us significantly during the difficult times of the past seven
(7) years now sustains us and encourages us to continue the fight for GLBT
rights. As a society, we should encourage and support our fellow man as
the GLBT community has done for our family.
It saddens us that the President and Senate Majority Leadership, in the
guise of protecting the institution of marriage, are using the lives and
jeopardizing the futures of GLBT individuals and their families for
political gain leading up to the 2006 mid-term elections. In their
opinion, marriage between a man and a woman needs to be protected or the
world as they know it will collapse along with modern society. It ain’t
so. During the course of our 33-year marriage, the only time our family
has needed protection is when hatred and discrimination took the life of
our son Matthew.
This is the same type of regressive thinking that led to prohibition
(which failed and the Constitutional amendment was repealed) and racial
discrimination and segregation (which also failed). Will modern
civilization disappear if same sex marriages are recognized as having the
same equal rights as those of opposite sex marriages? Only in the closed
minds of those currently in political power, especially the older
generation, who think it is their duty and God-given right to tell the
younger generation what is right and what is wrong; only in the closed
minds of those in political power who are worried about the fact that the
‘younger generation’ is more open-minded and accepting of diversity of
all kinds, including same-sex marriage; only in the closed minds of those
in political power who are worried about losing an election over other
domestic and international policy failures; and only in the closed minds
of those fundamentalist church groups who are attempting to purchase a
Constitutional amendment through political votes and donations to justify
their existence. As far as the President and Senate Majority Leadership
are concerned, it’s okay to take away the rights of a significant
portion of taxpaying, God-fearing Americans, as long as it isn’t them
losing those rights, privileges, and, possibly, families.
Since when is it wrong for a gay American to want to fight for, and
protect, the country of birth by serving in the military? Where is the
threat to our family and the families of other Americans? Our biggest
threats come from an ineffective President and Senate Majority Leadership
that can’t conclude a war, can’t improve the current state of the
educational system, can’t provide decent health care for every American,
can’t reform the Social Security and Medicare system to prevent them
from going broke, can’t protect our borders, can’t reduce the debt,
and can’t bring back the world-wide goodwill, integrity, and reputation
that America held before the second Gulf War.
Everything is a ‘can’t’ so the obvious solution to these problems
is to focus on an issue that half the country believes is a non-issue—gay
marriage. Why? It turns attention away from the real problems and keeps
the religious right happy that something is going to be done. It’s so
obvious that an Amendment will not pass. But it allows the President and
Senate Majority Leadership a so-called "photo-op"—an
opportunity to put on a public display of good intentions, letting them
pretend to do what is good for America in order to reach for those all
important votes and donations,
Anyone who believes the hatred behind this amendment is any different
than the hatred that led to our son’s murder is fooling themselves and
doesn’t understand what is happening every day in our society. Instead
of trying to enshrine discrimination into the U.S. Constitution for a
threat that does not exist, let’s spend the time more wisely by building
and supporting rights for all citizens to work, play, marry, raise
families and live in a country that was founded on the proposition that
all citizens are accorded equal rights.
Judy and Dennis Shepard are the parents of Matthew Shepard, who was
killed in an anti-gay hate crime in Wyoming in 1998. Matthew’s death
touched the hearts and souls of millions across this country and ignited a
media focus on the issue of hate in our society. The Matthew Shepard
Foundation, founded by Judy & Dennis, seeks to "Replace Hate with
Understanding, Compassion & Acceptance" through its varied
educational programs and by continuing to tell Matthew’s story. For
information, please visit