How Queer Was the Weimar Era in Germany?
The era of the Weimar Republic (1918-1933) witnessed a flourishing of
the arts, liberalization of social attitudes, and the emergence of a
vibrant queer culture in Berlin and other German cities. But a
conservative backlash, economic depression, and the rise of the Nazi
regime reversed this progress after little more than a decade.
Like much of Europe, Germany was devastated by World War I. Hungry for
peace and eager for change, the country ousted the monarchy of Kaiser
Wilhelm II in November 1918 and instituted a parliamentary democracy led
by the Socialists. The following year, the legislature drafted a new
constitution granting gender and class equality, privacy rights, and
individual liberties such as freedom of speech and assembly.
Thus began an era of remarkable artistic and intellectual ferment. The
realms of literature, drama, music, architecture, and the new medium of
film exploded. Philosophy and political theory enjoyed a renaissance as
well, and medicine and science flourished, with new advances in fields
ranging from psychology to physics.
Gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender people were in the thick of
these developments. By this time, Germany already had the strongest gay
rights movement in the world. In 1897, Dr. Magnus Hirschfeld and others
had founded the Scientific Humanitarian Committee—the first-ever
homosexual rights group—devoted to reform of Paragraph 175, the German
law criminalizing sex between men. In 1919, Hirschfeld opened the
Institute for Sexual Science in Berlin, which housed a library, museum,
and clinic. The movement was even large enough to have internal schisms:
Adolf Brand’s Gemeinschaft der Eigenen (Community of Self-Owners),
founded in 1903, celebrated masculine culture and rejected Hirschfeld’s
medicalized view of homosexuality.
Gay social life flourished during the 1920s. While there were hubs of
activity in cities such as Hamburg, Munich, and Cologne, Berlin was
without doubt the center of queer culture. Attracted by the heady
atmosphere and a weak currency that made living relatively cheap, gays and
lesbians flocked to the capital from across Germany and around the world.
By one estimate, there were 350,000 gay men and women among the city’s
four million residents.
An active cabaret culture emerged, complete with venues catering to
every sexual proclivity—as portrayed in gay British author Christopher
Isherwood’s Goodbye to Berlin (1939), which inspired the play and film
Cabaret. Berlin boasted dozens of gay, lesbian, and transvestite
nightclubs, leading Hirschfeld to note that "Uranians [his term for
homosexuals] have been seen arriving from the depths of the provinces
weeping tears of joy at the sight of this spectacle." Many such
venues were concentrated in the Scho[+um]neberg and Nollendorfplatz
neighborhoods, which remain centers of gay life today. One of these, the
Eldorado Nightclub on Motzstrasse, sported large signs over the entrance
announcing "You’ve found it!" and "It’s OK Here!"
In addition, there were numerous cafes, bathhouses, fetish clubs,
bookstores, theaters, and hotels—many operated by gay entrepreneurs—as
well as an estimated 2,000 male prostitutes.
Lesbian and bisexual women were active in mixed-gender homosexual
organizations such as the League for Human Rights, as well as in the
burgeoning women’s movement, working for educational reform and the
right to employment outside the home. By one estimate, there were some 50
lesbian venues and organizations in Berlin, including bars—often
frequented by butch/femme couples—salons, bowling clubs, and living
collectives. Several well-known lesbian literary figures called the city
home, including writer Christa Winsloe (author of the novel that was the
basis of the film Ma[+um]dchen in Uniform) and American journalist Dorothy
Thompson.
The new press freedom encouraged the establishment of some 30 queer
literary and political publications, which were sold openly on newsstands
and boasted a combined circulation in the millions. Among these were Brand’s
Der Eigene (One’s Own)—thought to be the first-ever gay magazine—Die
Freundschaft (Friendship), Die Insel (The Island), Frauenliebe (Women’s
Love), and Garconne.
But many Germans, disturbed by the era’s cultural changes and
economic hardships, yearned for a return to traditional values. Religious
conservatives decried shifting gender roles and perceived vices such as
homosexuality, pornography, and abortion. The nation’s problems were
blamed on Communists, Jews, feminists, and homosexuals.
Adolf Hitler exploited these fears and prejudices to consolidate his
political power, aided by factionalism on the left. He was appointed
chancellor in January 1933, and the staged Reichstag fire the following
month provided a pretext for suspending civil liberties. In May, the
Institute for Sexual Science was sacked and its materials burned by
right-wing youth. Homosexual publications were banned and venues were
shuttered; the Eldorado was converted into a Nazi propaganda center.
In 1935, Paragraph 175 was strengthened. An estimated 5,000 to 15,000
accused homosexual men were sent to concentration camps. Amid this climate
of fear and isolation, an untold number of queer men and women went into
hiding, entered sham marriages, emigrated to safer countries, or committed
suicide.
Weimar Germany offers one of history’s most prescient lessons about
how liberalization can lead to backlash, and seemingly secure rights and
freedoms can be lost. In the words of cultural critic Marcus Bullock,
Weimar’s cultural renaissance was "remarkable for the way it
emerged from a catastrophe, more remarkable for the way it vanished into a
still greater catastrophe."
Liz Highleyman is a freelance writer and editor who has written widely
on health, sexuality, and politics. She can be reached in care of Letters
from CAMP Rehoboth or at