It’s All About Soul
What with being unemployed and all, I’ve had plenty of time to catch
up on my reading list. I’ve recently discovered a great series of books
by author Mark Thompson, a wonderful writer on GLBT issues. A few years
ago, I picked up a copy of Leather Folk by Thompson, and I couldn’t put
it down. In that book, Thompson dispels many of the stereotypes regarding
the leather community, and he explains leather culture in a way that is
both forthright and endearing. Now I’m studying his trio of books that
really digs into what makes GLBT people tick—Gay Soul, Gay Spirit, and
Gay Body.
In Gay Soul: Finding the Heart of Gay Spirit and Nature, Mark Thompson
interviews sixteen "writers, healers, teachers, and
visionaries," including such big names as Paul Monette, Harry Hay,
and Ram Dass. Gay Soul explores the history of the GLBT experience and how
it has shaped our place in society and our collective queer consciousness.
In his foreword, Thompson defines soul as "the repository of all that
I feel: my appetites and ambitions, sadness and joy." Thompson argues
that the gay soul does have a collective memory, and perhaps most
importantly, he points out that we did not always live the persecuted
existence we have faced in recent centuries. In fact, once upon a time,
queer people were cherished and revered, placed high upon a spiritual
pedestal.
I first learned of Native American berdache in a college Native
American history class. Although my professor was very knowledgeable and
open-minded, he didn’t spend much class time explaining the important
role the berdache played in tribal life, so I did some independent
research. Mark Thompson and his interviewees speak extensively about the
berdache in Gay Soul. The term berdache was invented by European settlers
of the Americas for a select and especially persecuted group of Native
Americans. In an effort to reclaim the wonderful history of the berdache,
many GLBT and Native American historians prefer the term
"two-spirited."
In tribal culture, the berdache, or "Two Spirits," were
individuals who often cross-dressed and performed the traditional tribal
functions of the opposite sex. Two-spirited men often cooked and created
beadwork and other crafts, while two-spirited women often hunted and even
led battles. There is little academic debate that many of these Two
Spirits were gay or lesbian. Two Spirits were revered as spiritual leaders
of their tribes. Many shaman, who in most cultures were held in regard
equal to that of tribal leaders, also cross-dressed and did not
participate in heterosexual relations. Shaman performed magical rites,
advised tribe members, maintained tribal history, and presided over the
all-important holidays and tribal ceremonies.
In modern culture, gender benders and queer folk are anything but
revered, often relegated to the most distant social margins. But many
tribal cultures recognized the great gifts of the berdache and the shaman.
Standing outside the male/female binary, these special people could look
inside the culture and critique it honestly. Perhaps most significantly,
berdache and shaman, according to tribal beliefs, were honored because
their bodies possessed the spiritual qualities of both genders, and so
they were a direct link to the spirit world. In tribal cultures, everyone
had a part to play in the survival of the tribe, so power hierarchies did
not work well. The person who planted corn was, in the long run, just as
important to the tribe’s survival as the leader, so each person brought
his or her own gifts to the table and there was no room for judgment or
prejudice.
As Mark Thompson and his subjects point out in Gay Soul, today’s
western society is predicated upon a binary system—men and women, rich
and poor, winners and losers. Tribal cultures not only could not afford to
indulge in an "us vs. them" mentality, but their spirituality
did not allow for it. The spiritual system of Native Americans was largely
earth-based, with emphasis on the cycle of life, not the accomplishments
of the individual if they did not contribute to the betterment of the
tribe. Possessing many of the qualities of what we would today call
"queer," the strong presence of berdache and shaman has been
documented in well over one hundred tribal cultures throughout the world,
from the Americas to Mesopotamia to Africa.
Gay Soul focuses on other subjects besides historical tribal culture.
The men interviewed by Thompson (he chooses to focus primarily on men so
as not to seem presumptuous about queer women’s spiritual history) hold
some fascinating views. One man asserts that queer people have a peculiar
energy that we can tap into if we just listen for it, and it will guide us
in our gifts and contributions to the universe. This assertion is very
much in line with modern theories of collective social consciousness and
recent scientific findings that memories are carried not only in our
brains, but also in the very cells of our bodies. One man asserts that the
beast of capitalism, and the binary system upon which is it is founded, is
dying. Frankly, with my recent lay-off and my bad feelings about our
power-hungry and shallow society, this particular assertion is especially
intriguing for me.
Gay Soul is worth much more than a quick read. It’s worth a
thoughtful, searching study. Now is a time when our own queer identities
are in transition, with assimilationist marriage rights knocking at our
door and the raging debate of whether or not transgender persons fit in
our movement. Now is a time when the political and religious right is so
focused against us, and our nation is polarized on political issues
including gay rights. European settlers targeted the berdache most of all
in their quest to wipe out Native American tribal customs, often gathering
them in groups and turning dogs upon them. They recognized that when you
eliminate the spiritual and cultural leaders of a group, you have
paralyzed its very heart. I think we could all use a little spiritual
awakening right now, some heart and some soul.
Eric Morrison lives in Wilmington, Delaware. He can be reached at