A Review, Kind Of
I do not know Fay Jacobs, I have never met Fay Jacobs, I do not
understand why anyone, including Fay Jacobs, would want a pet that cannot
purr, and, in the words of Bill Clinton (surprisingly concise, given that
it’s taken me a week to get through his childhood in My Life), I have
not had relations with that woman.
Impartiality firmly established? Good. BUY FAY’S BOOK! As I Lay
Frying comprises her wonderful 1995-2003 columns for Letters, recounting
the adventures of Fay, her partner Bonnie, their dogs, and their friends.
I haven’t met a more compelling cast of characters since reading the
"Little House" books when I was eight—that’s counting all
five Harry Potters, The Brothers Karamazov, and, you guessed it, My Life.
I’ve caught Fay’s columns on and off over the years. They’re
perfect as discrete pieces, as Fay has the good stand-up comic’s flare
for coming full circle—wrapping everything up neatly and getting one
last joke in before saying "Good night." They become a thing of
power, though, when arranged back-to-back in book form. You get a sense of
the passage of seasons, illnesses (and home improvement projects) suffered
and moved on from, growth happening…whether it be the growth of a person
coming further and further "out," the growth of a family
expanding to include new members (schnauzers, mainly), the growth of a
country passing through Y2K, Election Heist 2000, 9/11, and war in Iraq,
then bumping up against gay marriage…or the growth on Fay’s middle
finger (don’t ask; just read).
Years ago, my partner placed a fateful ad in the Blade saying
"Funny Girl Seeks Smarty Pants." I’m reminded of this whenever
I read Fay’s stuff. Fay’s a funny girl and a smarty pants, and
something else: a generous writer. I love a lot of humor columnists, but
there’s something different about Fay—you never get the sense that she
sat down to write with the sole purpose of being funny. She’s also
different from most memoirists, in that her tone never suggests
self-importance or "Look at Me!"-ness. When’s the last time
you read a memoir and thought of the writer as "generous" for
letting you in on his or her life?
(Note to fellow Clinton readers: Fay’s not too generous. Sentences
such as "I enjoyed going to the basement to type new names and
addresses on plates and put them in file drawers" [My Life, pg. 93]
are absent from As I Lay Frying.)
With its 3-4 page segments, As I Lay Frying is great for beach, bed, or
bathroom readers, who tend to fall asleep—or flush—after only a few
minutes of reading. Of course, it’s also good for people who like to
plow right through a book (I’m one of ’em), but my point is: even if
you’re not a "big" reader, you’ll dig this book. You’ll
re-read passages because you want to, not because you have to, having
forgotten what happened since you last sat down to, um, read. This format
and the local relevance also make it the perfect book to keep on your
guest room’s bedside table or leave in the living room for trustworthy
renters to discover.
Suckers for a great turn of phrase (again, I’m one of ’em) will get
giddy just flipping through As I Lay Frying. Fay’s worth reading for her
similes alone: a computer freezes up like "a lesbian in a roomful of
Promise Keepers"; an animal rescue lady’s small car is
"packed, like a Rubik’s Cube, with a dozen cages." And though
her essays will inevitably be referred to in Friends-episode format (The
One About the Scrapple Bust; The One About the Pair of Dykes), Fay writes
great titles, including "My Life as Ballast," "Counting
Blessings Instead of Sheep," and, for the column covering her and
Bonnie’s wedding, the jubilant and moving "We Did, We Did."
All this Book Review Hoo-ha, though, is less important than what I
really want to say about Fay’s book.
It made me happy.
I think it will you, too.