Artist: Tori Amos
Album: American Doll Posse
Label: Epic
In 2006 upon completing the keyboard-shaped box set, A Piano, Tori Amos
announced that she was entering a new stage of her music. American Doll
Posse arrives after 2005’s The Beekeeper and Amos’ direction has led
her to a rock heavy sound. The new record showcases Amos marking a
creative stretch—she is accompanied by four imaginary girls who make up
the "posse": Clyde, Santa, Isabel, Pip and Tori are to be the
summation of a complete woman. Inspired by Greek literature and the
demeaning sexuality of current times, Amos has created a concept album for
the modern female.
The treat American Doll Posse really offers the Toriphile and the
casual listener is not the presumptuous concept (though it is an artistic
feat—can the modern woman be summarized in a mere 24 songs?) or the
well-developed characters in the "posse" (they have their own
Myspace blogs and wardrobe), but the most raucous music she’s made in a
while. Tori always has been moving musically and thematically in one way
or the other. Both her slow/sensuous and aggressive songs of yesteryear
have been imbued with the same spirit of rebellious artistry. Never been
one to make a banal record, Tori is an untamed fire of creativity.
American Doll Posse is proof.
From the up-beat gospel stomp of "Big Wheel" (including the
defining "M-I-L-F" call-out at the end [not even Madonna has
gone there yet]) to the harsh, cutting glam of "Teenage
Hustling" Posse introduces the audience to a musically edgier
tableaux. A good percentage of similar songs— whether more pop oriented
("Beauty of Speed") Marilyn Manson at a piano bar, ("Body
and Soul") or painfully concise ("Devils and Gods")—give
the record a meatier appeal.
Of course, this does not mean she’s traded in her artistic ideals in
for meaningless pop blather. All the songs on American Doll Posse reflect
the trials and tribulations (more likely the realizations and hurdles) of
the modern woman. All five characters exude many traits: they’re
reflective ("Secret Spell"), critical, ("Yo George")
religious ("Body and Soul"), and poignant, ("Roosterspur
Bridge"). There are some calamities though. "Programmable
Soda" is ridiculous; "Velvet Revolution" sounds trite.
"Smokey Joe" is abstract and murky and "Posse Bonus"
is simply a waste of good time.
New sounds aside, some of Amos’ most compelling work is here.
"Girl Disappearing," a moving ballad including a swelling string
quartet has a haunted glow. This is probably her most effective song on
the record. The mellow "Father’s Son" is equally lugubrious.
"Dragon," which closes Posse, is a tender plea to "Stay
awhile…. Won’t you lay here with me and I will bring kisses for the
beast." It is a rather genuine way to end a chaotic album with Amos’
electric piano adding a hazy glaze over the song.
Indeed, Amos covers a lot of new ground. The good news is that she
doesn’t employ any egregious method of differentiating one of the posse
girls from another (no histrionic voices, no accents). The bad news: the
existence of the five characters is superfluous. They are unnecessary as
one can appreciate the record without their presence. It is also
unfortunate that the concept doesn’t add much weight to the record, if
anything it mucks things up. In the end it is merely fun for Tori and her
fans.
Blair Fraipont is a Rehoboth transplant, now living in New York
City. E-mail him at blairfraipont@gmail.com.