Rock Rules, As Show Tunes Make Final Curtain Call
My older friend Bruce (and I’m delighted to say I still have a few
friends who are riper in age than me) loves vintage show tunes and pop
standards. Ever since he signed up for satellite television, he has
constantly played the big-band station included in his package,
incessantly singing along to the verses of Carol Channing’s "Hello
Dolly," Ethel Merman’s "There’s No Business Like Show
Business" and Doris Day’s "Que Sera Sera." He even does a
little barking sound during the chorus of Patti Page’s "How Much is
That Doggie in the Window?"
Younger visitors to his home routinely furrow their brows, regarding
his nonstop song-and-dance act a feeble attempt to distract them from the
domino and card parties he hosts and usually wins. But Bruce can’t help
himself. He’s a relic of a time when, if you were a gay man, it was
almost a prerequisite to listen to a lot of Judy Garland and Barbra
Streisand. And one’s record collection was considered incomplete without
a copy of Gypsy or My Fair Lady.
Certainly, some of the passion for music from the 1940s and 50s was
generational, but myths and stereotypes die hard. As someone who grew up
in the early age of rock ‘n roll, I never felt comfortable squeezed into
the Broadway pigeonhole (except for an occasional teary-eyed playing of
The Sound of Music soundtrack). Still, when I first came out in the early
1970s, I felt obliged to augment my collection of Jefferson Airplane,
Buffalo
Springfield and Doors albums with a little Liza-with-a-Z. I truly
believed that I would be rejected as an openly gay man if I didn’t own
at least one Garland anthology, a Johnny Mathis LP, and a Streisand or
two.
I kept them where they were quite visible, but I rarely played them
except during intimate dinner parties, and even then I wasn’t
particularly fond of most of the music. It seemed relatively lifeless
compared to my Janis Joplin, Cat Stevens, Who, and Stevie Wonder albums.
To me, the golden age of Broadway musicals began with Hair and ended with
Evita and La Cage aux Folles.
So, I’m pleased to see that the mythic era of the show tune-slash-pop
standard as de rigueur music for gay guys is making what may be its final
curtain call. A recent online survey by Out Magazine asked gay readers
what kind of music they preferred, and a measly 5.4 percent responded
"Broadway" or "standards." Only jazz fared less well
(2.9 percent), with even hip hop beating out the golden-olden boys in the
big bands.
The most listened-to music among gay folks these days, according to the
poll, is alternative and contemporary hard rock, followed closely by pop.
The two categories accounted for more than 52 percent of all responses.
Dance and electronica came in third at 18.4 percent.
Although the trend-driven tastes of younger music consumers account for
some of the change, the relative popularity of musical genres still
amounts to a significant shift in the paradigm of gay culture. And as rock
gains ground as the favored style of music for gay folks, more of its
lyrics speak personally to us. Take Scottish nouveau-punk rockers Franz
Ferdinand. Their self-titled debut album has been an international smash
for more than a year, powered by the out-front lyrics of "(Come Dance
with Me) Michael."
"You’re the boy with all the leather hips, sticky hair, sticky
lips; stumble on my sticky lips," the guys sing most convincingly.
Along with Ferdinand, whose new release "You Could Have It So Much
Better" is also a hot commodity, the best selling modern rock albums
among gay customers in our Florida shop include Gnarls Barkley’s St.
Elsewhere (Cee-Lo’s voice on the hit track "Crazy" is simply
mesmerizing), James Blunt’s lyrically potent Bedlam, Aqualung’s lush
Strange and Beautiful and The Killers’ well-described Hot Fuss. Among
more veteran rock artists, Green Day’s American Idiot has become a
contemporary classic, as has the deluxe edition of greatest hits by a
woman who helped make it safe for gay people to proclaim their love of
rock ‘n roll: Melissa Etheridge.
In the dance category, one of the current hottest CDs is European diva
Cascada’s Everytime We Touch. It’s got a retro groove that recalls the
golden era of disco.
And for those who mourn the good old days of big-band music, young
Michael Bublé’s collection of updated pop standards, It’s Time,
performs well (much better than either Rod Stewart’s or Barry Manilow’s
similarly themed but less perky tributes to the past).
Perhaps the best thing about music today is that, whatever one’s
taste, the choices are nearly infinite. Almost every song ever sung,
almost every album ever recorded is available in some form on the
internet. Satellite radio (and television) services include stations
focusing on every genre from my favorite rock ‘n roll oldies (Dion and
Del Shannon) to hip-hop to those show tunes pal Bruce can’t stop
singing.
You don’t have to follow the crowd in your musical tastes, but I’m
happy to see an ever-larger gay crowd proclaim rock as their favorite. The
genre has evolved and changed considerably over the half century since
artists like Little Richard, Chuck Berry and Elvis pioneered it, but that’s
undoubtedly why it remains the major musical force on our planet. As we
early fans predicted all along, rock ‘n roll will never die.
Bill Sievert, a former resident of Rehoboth Beach, is editor and
co-publisher of Pulse, a new alternative community magazine in Central
Florida. He also co-owns an urban-contemporary general store The Wow
Factory in Mount Dora, Florida. He can be reached at