No Wonder Lesbian Couple Scares Opponents
Holding hands and standing on the steps of the courthouse in Tampa,
Florida, on July 20, Nancy Wilson and Paula Schoenwether didn’t make a
frightening picture. Indeed, they made a loving one.
But these two women standing together publicly and showing affection for
each other after 27 years as a couple is exactly what political and social
conservatives, and particularly the religious right, have been dreading and
warning the rest of the nation about ever since Massachusetts’ highest
court ruled that gay and lesbian couples had a right to wed in that state.
Wilson and Schoenwether traveled to Massachusetts earlier in the month,
and on July 2, the women wed in Provincetown. Now, they are trying to export
their love to other states.
The reason the couple stood together on the Tampa courthouse was to
announce that in the little red folder carried by their attorney, Miami
lawyer Ellis Rubin, was a lawsuit challenging the federal government to make
other states recognize their Massachusetts marriage. They are the first gay
or lesbian couple in the country to file such a lawsuit.
Legal experts, including those working for gay and lesbian organizations
that are trying to legalize same-sex marriage in places beyond just
Massachusetts, say the lawsuit does not have a strong chance. Some gay and
lesbian advocates have even been very critical of the lawsuit. They are
worried that if it fails, it might actually hurt rather than help the
advancement of securing same-sex marriage rights.
Wilson and Schoenwether know they face an uphill battle.
"We know this could be a long uphill battle and that this might not
be the lawsuit that breaks everything wide open," Schoenwether told the
St. Petersburg Times. "But we also believe we should do what we can,
that we have an obligation to at least try."
"No one has anything to be afraid of by recognizing our
marriage," Wilson said that day as the two women stood side by side,
beaming.
As much as I hope these two women win their long-shot lawsuit, and as
much as I want same-sex marriage to be legalized in ever state, I must
respectfully disagree with Wilson.
Those who are so viciously and vehemently opposed to gay and lesbian
marriage have a lot to fear from people like Nancy Wilson and Paula
Schoenwether, and our foes know it.
In many ways, Wilson and Schoenwether are the lesbian version of an Ozzie
and Harriet marriage.
For starters, the two met in church.
It was the late 1970s, and Schoenwether was teaching school in Detroit,
Michigan. At the time, she was very closeted. She was scared to death that
school officials would discover her sexual orientation, and she would lose
her job. If her mother found out she was a lesbian, Schoenwether fretted,
her mother might disown her.
On the advice of a friend, Schoenwether, who didn’t feel welcomed as a
lesbian in most straight churches of the day, made a visit to the
Metropolitan Community Church, which caters to gay and lesbian Christians.
There, she met Nancy Wilson, a New York native who had moved in 1975 to
Detroit from Boston to be the pastor of MCC.
Schoenwether says she still remembers asking Wilson out. Almost three
decades later, the two women are still together—a feat for any couple,
regardless of their sexual orientation.
In those nearly three decades, the two women have shared a life of good
times and bad, of struggles and achievements, of hopes and disappointments
and successes.
Not long after the two women started seeing each other, rumors began
circulating at the Detroit school where Schoenwether taught that she was a
lesbian. She suffered ridicule from the students. In the teachers’ lounge,
her coworkers would whisper about her.
Then, in 1979, the two women moved to Los Angeles, where Wilson became
the clerk of the Board of Elders for MCC. Later, she would become the pastor
there.
Schoenwether went back to school, getting a master’s and a doctorate in
clinical psychology. She opened a practice where she specialized in
counseling gay and lesbian couples.
In Los Angeles, life changed dramatically for the two women, especially
Schoenwether. No longer closeted, she took up gay and lesbian activism, a
charge that still has hold of her a little, and probably has influence on
her decision to file this lawsuit.
Three years ago, the couple moved again, this time settling in Bradenton,
Florida. Wilson is still with MCC, now the senior pastor at Trinity MCC in
Sarasota. Schoenwether has given up her counseling career, and traded it in
for a camera. She now works as a photographer.
Along their path together, through moves and coming out and job changes
and parents dying, the two women, like any committed couple, have stood by
each other as solidly and surely as they stood hand-in-hand on the
courthouse steps in Tampa.
You can’t see all the details of their history when you look at them,
or when you see photographs of them in the papers.
But what you see is the kind of quiet strength and dignity that comes
when two people have spent their lives loving one another. I saw it when I
looked at the pictures of these two women daring to stand up against the
federal government and Congress and the hateful lawmakers in so many states
who would deny everything they stand for and have meant to each other.
I’m guessing that others saw it, too. Including members of the
religious right and the politicians who make their careers out of scaring
straight people with the thought that a gay marriage somehow threatens them.
I suspect plenty of straight people saw it, as well; people who may or
may not be in favor of letting gays and lesbians marry, but people who are
married themselves, who have also been through job changes and moves and
parental loss, and all the other things that life throws at two people who
stick together for three decades of love and commitment. I’m betting that
even the straight fence-sitters on gay marriage saw something of themselves
reflected in the strong and determined faces of these two women that day as
they stood holding hands on the Tampa courthouse steps.
No wonder Nancy Wilson and Paula Schoenwether scare so many opponents of
same-sex marriage.
Mubarak Dahir receives e-mail at