McGreevey: It’s a Sad Story
In a stunning announcement, New Jersey Governor James McGreevey told a
press conference "I am a Gay American." Now New Jersey citizens
will have a few months to see what it’s like to be governed by an openly
gay man. I believe that all citizens of good conscience should step
forward and say that whether Governor McGreevey is gay or straight is not
important, or likely to have any effect on how he will govern. There may
be other issues that will make James McGreevey unfit for office, but we
should make it clear that just being gay is not one of them.
I understand that many in New Jersey may feel they elected a man based
on his policies, principles and ideals as he presented them. I also
understand that many may now feel those ideals may be different than what
they thought they were. But it is up to people of good will, especially
the gay and lesbian citizens of New Jersey, to explain to everyone why
James McGreevey, or anyone else that comes out, would now be a much freer
man to follow his heart and to make decisions without the constant fear of
being found out.
We live in difficult times for gays and lesbians of a certain age.
There may be the desire to come out, but the reality that often exists, as
it does for McGreevey, is of a lifetime of hiding in the closet and having
a wife and family. I feel for his family, having to go through this in
such a public way. It is hard enough to deal with this in private as many
families have had to over the years.
But the reality is that society has forced so many of us to spend years
in the closet because we could not follow our dreams if we came out. Those
of us over 40 knew we couldn’t run for elected office if we were openly
gay and hope to win, and in many cases were shut out of jobs and sometimes
even housing. We couldn’t serve our country and we often wouldn’t be
welcomed within our own families.
A man like McGreevey was told from the time he could understand that
there was only one way to grow up and that was straight. He was told by
his church, his family, his community and society, that to be viewed as a
successful man he had to grow up and get married, to a woman, and have
children (preferably 2.3 of them). That to do anything else would leave
him suspect to being different from the norm and someone to be feared and
ostracized. Now they forgot to tell him that over 60 percent of marriages
end in divorce and that we know that up to 10 percent of the population is
gay. But society has often deemed these facts irrelevant. Divorce doesn’t
end your career and gay people were kept in the closet so didn’t have to
be dealt with at all.
Society is slowly changing, but slowly is the operative word. We have
more and more of the young GLBT community growing up out of the closet,
and groups like PFLAG trying to help them and their parents deal with
their being gay and what it will mean to their future. We see more and
more positive images of gay people in the community and in the media. As
Congresspeople, local government officials and business leaders begin to
come out, people are beginning to recognize that gay and lesbian people
are just like them. Today it’s harder to find a person who doesn’t
know a gay person or live near an openly gay person. They are their
doctors, lawyers, teachers, bankers, florists, designers and the writers
of the plays they see and the music they listen to. But with all this we
still have a society that won’t accept the GLBT community as full
citizens. There is still something about us that scares them. And the idea
of our marriages scares them enough to try to pass a constitutional
amendment against it.
I’m not sure exactly what the fear is about, except that anything
different and hard to understand often creates fear. And then there is
that heightened fear when someone like James McGreevey comes out that it
could be anyone. He is the picture of the successful man we older men have
been told to be. He has been married, actually twice, for many years, has
two beautiful children, success in life and has even been elected by the
public to high office. The fear has to be if a man like that could be gay,
than anyone could, and that seems to be scary.
McGreevey in Office would be a symbol to so many of what we can be and
out of Office is a prime example of why staying in the closet never works
in the long run. One can’t hide their feelings forever or disregard the
essence of who they are. Being gay is not the only thing we are, but our
sexuality is a strong part of our being and can’t be hidden forever
without severe repercussions to our inner beings. There are many high
level government officials, past and present that are gay and still in the
closet. They include US Senators, at least one former Governor I know of,
Cabinet Secretaries and officials in the UN. If some of these people would
find it in their hearts to come out, and speak out, they would be doing a
service not only to the GLBT community but to society as a whole. It would
help people to see and understand that there are people out there who they
respect and trust with their lives even though they happen to be gay. I
have written before that I oppose outing people, unless they are elected
and then fight our community. But some of these people, past and present
high level officials, support our community and have no wives, husbands or
children, and I would hope that some of them would decide they owe it to
those that will follow them to come out on their own.
It is so important because once they do, the gay and lesbian youth
growing up today, and in the future, will find it acceptable to come out
before they get married to someone of the opposite sex, or run for public
office or just run away from who they are. They will be able to live their
lives fully and openly, and if they choose, work in positions of authority
where the public will learn to vote on or accept their work without regard
to their sexual orientation.
I have hope that this will happen in my lifetime. But I know that
either way I will continue to fight and to work to see that when someone
like McGreevey is forced out of the closet, for whatever reason, the fact
of their being gay alone will not be a reason for them to leave their jobs
or lose their careers.
Peter Rosenstein, a regular contributor to Letters from CAMP
Rehoboth, may be reached at