The evolution of the Folsom Street Fair—the world’s largest
leather/SM/fetish event—reflects the history of both an urban neighborhood
facing development pressures and a gay community confronting a devastating
epidemic.
San Francisco’s South of Market district, or SoMa, was long a
mixed-use, working-class neighborhood of warehouses, service businesses, and
residential hotels, populated by seamen, longshore workers, bohemian
artists, and immigrant families. By the 1960s it was home to some of the
city’s earliest LGBT institutions, including the country’s first gay
community center (opened by the Society for Individual Rights in 1966) and
the office of the Daughters of Bilitis.
The area’s cheap rents and deserted nighttime streets also attracted a
burgeoning gay male leather community, whose members eschewed stereotypical
queer effeminacy for a more masculine style. The first SoMa leather bar, the
Tool Box, opened in 1962; it gained renown when a photo of the bar, with its
mural by Chuck Arnett, appeared in a 1964 Life magazine article entitled
"Homosexuality in America."
For the next two decades, leather bars and bathhouses proliferated around
Folsom Street, while the neighborhood’s narrow alleys proved ideal for
cruising. Among the most popular haunts were the Ambush (which boasted its
own brand of poppers), the Barracks (described by author and former Drummer
editor Jack Fritscher as "a four-story maze of fantasy sex"), the
Brig, Febe’s (with its trademark mascot, Michelangelo’s David dressed as
a leatherman), and the Slot. During this golden age, according to Fritscher,
"peace, love, and granola would mix with hard leather, hard drugs, and
hard sex," and the streets of SoMa hummed with sexual excitement and
camaraderie.
But all was not well along the so-called "Miracle Mile." SoMa
had been eyed for urban renewal since the late 1940s, but redevelopment
pressure increased in the late ‘60s and again in the late ‘70s - aided
by a new pro-development mayor, Dianne Feinstein, who had assumed the
position following the 1978 assassination of Mayor George Moscone and gay
Supervisor Harvey Milk. In 1981, a large fire at the site of the Barracks
bathhouse (by then closed and under renovation as a hotel) consumed more
than 20 buildings and left many residents homeless. And in the early 1980s,
AIDS hit SoMa hard, decimating the leather community.
The resulting hysteria led the health department to close the city’s
bathhouses and sex clubs in 1984, striking a further blow to the area’s
economic and cultural institutions.
To combat the threats facing the neighborhood, a coalition came together
that included progressive ministers, social-service providers, old-time
labor organizers, small-business owners, affordable-housing advocates, and
GLBT activists. Among them were Michael Valerio, an openly gay man of
Filipino/ Hispanic heritage, and Kathleen Connell, an out lesbian with a
long history of activism. Valerio and Connell were impressed with how Milk
had used the Castro Street Fair (a street party celebrating the city’s
gayest neighborhood) as a platform for political organizing and community
building, and Milk’s successor, gay Supervisor Harry Britt, urged them to
follow suit.
The first Folsom Street Fair—dubbed "Megahood"—took place
in 1984 on the autumnal equinox. The event, featuring local craftspeople, a
dance stage, and a variety of performers, brought together the diverse
elements of the neighborhood and demonstrated that, far from being a
blighted slum, SoMa was a vital part of the city. "As a neighborhood or
place of work, South of Market magnetically attracts the pioneers, the
changelings, the cutting edge of industry, arts, entertainment, human and
social relationships," read the fair’s first invitation.
"Not too far behind the concrete facades, a pulsating, living
mosaic-like community is alive and well."
Around the same time, another group was organizing to help the leather
community cope with the impact of AIDS. To raise both funds and community
spirits, Jerry Vallaire and International Mr. Leather Patrick Toner launched
a second street fair in August 1985 on Ringold Alley, an infamous SoMa
cruising strip. Two years later, under pressure from residents, this fair
moved to nearby Dore Alley. In 1990, facing volunteer burnout, the
organizers of the Folsom Street and "Up Your Alley" fairs decided
to combine their efforts and create South of Market Merchants’ and
Individuals’ Lifestyle Events (SMMILE), which now produces both events and
puts out an annual Bare Chest Calendar.
In the late 1990s, the Folsom Street Fair experienced a revival as it
increasingly drew leather and fetish aficionados from across the country and
around the world—and spanning the spectrum of sexual orientations. Dressed
in their fetish finery—or sometimes nothing at all—fairgoers can
purchase wares from internationally known leather craftspeople, listen to
bands, give or receive a spanking for charity, or simply see and be seen.
Many organizations began holding events in conjunction with the one-day
fair, during what is now known as Leather Week. Today, the Folsom Street
Fair is California’s third largest public event, drawing hundreds of
thousands of participants each year and raising a similar amount of money
for community organizations.
Liz Highleyman can be reached in care of Letters
from CAMP Rehoboth or at